The Brewster Store was orginally a church built in 1852 but became a general store serving residents off and on since 1866. The Brewster Store features Brewster Store fudge, soft water taffy, old-fashioned assorted penny candy, Beanie Babies, books and much more. Address: 1935 Main St Brewster MA USA 02631 Send an Email 1 508 896-3744